No two Mississippi Mud Pies are exactly alike, so they say. They can have multiple layers, chocolate sauce or meringue, graham cracker, even real chocolates. While the origins of this delicious treat are known, a single recipe or even a first one are a mystery, and it only lends to the aura of this deeply sweet and chocolaty treat. For visitors, the fact that you are reading about such a sophisticated desert being offered at a restaurant with the name “pizza” at the end of it, may be a little confusing. So let us locals tell you that Edgartown Pizza is just a name and not at all an end description to a restaurant who is known just as much for their varied dinner and desert menu as they are for their delicious pizza pies. The Mississippi Mud Pie is a perfect example of just how far they will go to satisfy every taste bud of every person, everywhere, at any time. That’s Edgartown Pizza! Layered with Chocolate custard, Brownie, Chocolate sauce and Chocolate Cake, you might think this would be enough, but wait ….that’s not all. They just had to add some real chocolates to top it off, literally. This is a desert so rich and thick and gooey that its almost impossible to eat it alone. Good Thing it comes in a clear to-go container because chances are you will need it. If you have a chocolate craving, and pretty much anyone reading a piece titled “Sweet Tooth” will, head to Edgartown Pizza and try the Mississippi Mud Pie. Your Sweet tooth will thank you!
